RANDOM CAPTAIN 58—FULL Topic

Random Captain 58 is here!



You will receive THREE Random Captain candidates via random.org, each with 18 or more MLB seasons.

You will choose ONE of these three players to be your Random Captain
. You will draft one of his seasons, then draft 24 of his teammates from his entire career (no twisting) to fill out your roster.

OTHER RULES

90M cap
NO: CLONES, WW, TRADES, AAA, DH
Random alignment
Park must be one that your captain called home at some point in his career


Once we're full, I'll ask a Hall of Fame owner not in this league to randomize a list of numbers between 1 and 165. The numbers 1-165 represent the possible captains in the post below; the order they appear in will determine which owner gets which captain. That is, the first owner on the list below (me) will get the first 3 numbers, the second owner (mensu1954) will get the next 3 numbers, and so on.

Owners are listed below in the order they signed up.

OWNER -- RANDOM CAPTAIN OPTIONS

1. crazystengel -- Willie McGee, Tony Gwynn, Dennis Eckersley
2. mensu1954 -- Yadier Molina, Ernie Banks, Nelson Cruz
3. SAKABAKBRG -- Clarence Mitchell, Dwight Evans, Fred Clarke
4. joerat1 -- Jim Dwyer, Raphael Palmeiro, Bill Russell
5. DougDoty -- Terry Mulholland, Edgar Martinez, Rick Cerone
6. rmarsh915 -- Mike Mussina, Lenny Harris, Ellis Burks
7. newarkwilder -- Mike Flanagan, Murry Dickson, Ozzie Smith
8. SteveIzzy -- Dave Parker, Joe Kuhel, Mickey Mantle
9. thaneoffife -- Lew Burdette, Gabby Hartnett, Ed Kranepool
10. gees51 -- Dale Murphy, Walter Johnson, Carl Yastrzemski
11. halo23 -- Sammy Sosa, C.C. Sabathia, Tommy Davis
12. DarthDurron -- Kent Mercker, Aramis Ramírez, Yogi Berra
13. scjensen51 -- Wally Schang, Dixie Walker, Raúl Ibañez
14. atheistdeals -- Andy Pettitte, Rick Sutcliffe, George Foster
15. winnetka1 -- Juan Pizarro, Duke Snider, Lloyd Waner
16. alleyviper -- Orel Hershiser, Mike Timlin, Adam Wainwright
17. akira_hokuto -- Elmer Valo, Ted Lyons, Adrian Beltre
18. andyd2008 -- Tom Paciorek, Chris Speier, Jay Bell
19. redwingscup -- Wade Boggs, Hal McRae, Jack Clark
20. bob_shabazz -- Jesse Haines, Greg Myers, Manny Ramirez
21. mcbillsfan -- George Brett, Dutch Leonard (1933-1953), Goose Goslin
22. gilh14 -- Rube Marquard, Rod Carew, Lave Cross
23. contrarian23 -- Johnny Evers, Mike Torrez, Al Leiter
24. dhomard -- Gene Garber, Mark Belanger, Walker Cooper

WAITLIST

1.
2.


RANDOM CAPTAIN HISTORY & RECORDS
4/3/2025 12:23 AM (edited)
POSSIBLE RANDOM CAPTAINS
  1. Hank Aaron
  2. Doyle Alexander
  3. Luis Aparicio
  4. Luke Appling
  5. Brad Ausmus
  6. Jimmy Austin
  7. Ernie Banks
  8. Dick Bartell
  9. Miguel Batista
  10. Don Baylor
  11. Mark Belanger
  12. Buddy Bell
  13. Jay Bell
  14. Carlos Beltran
  15. Adrian Beltre
  16. Yogi Berra
  17. Ossie Bluege
  18. Bert Blyleven
  19. Wade Boggs
  20. Rube Bressler
  21. George Brett
  22. Lew Burdette
  23. Smoky Burgess
  24. Ellis Burks
  25. Roy Campanella
  26. José Cardenal
  27. Rod Carew
  28. Phil Cavarretta
  29. Rick Cerone
  30. Jack Clark
  31. Fred Clarke
  32. Roberto Clemente
  33. Bartolo Colon
  34. Walker Cooper
  35. Lave Cross
  36. Nelson Cruz
  37. Kiki Cuyler
  38. Johnny Damon
  39. Tommy Davis
  40. Willie Davis
  41. Murry Dickson
  42. Shawon Dunston
  43. Jim Dwyer
  44. Dennis Eckersley
  45. Dwight Evans
  46. Johnny Evers
  47. Bob Feller
  48. Rick Ferrell
  49. Mike Flanagan
  50. George Foster
  51. Nellie Fox
  52. John Franco
  53. John Fregosi
  54. Frankie Frisch
  55. Woodie Fryman
  56. Gene Garber
  57. Goose Goslin
  58. Alfredo Griffin
  59. Tony Gwynn
  60. Jesse Haines
  61. Lenny Harris
  62. Gabby Hartnett
  63. LaTroy Hawkins
  64. Richie Hebner
  65. George Hendrick
  66. Orel Hershiser
  67. Gil Hodges
  68. Trevor Hoffman
  69. Willie Horton
  70. Raúl Ibañez
  71. Grant Jackson
  72. Reggie Jackson
  73. Charlie Jamieson
  74. Walter Johnson
  75. Johnny Klippstein
  76. Ed Kranepool
  77. Joe Kuhel
  78. Charlie Jamieson
  79. Nap Lajoie
  80. Al Leiter
  81. Dutch Leonard (1933-1953)
  82. Sherm Lollar
  83. Ted Lyons
  84. Mickey Mantle
  85. Rube Marquard
  86. Edgar Martinez
  87. Pedro Martinez
  88. Lee May
  89. Hal McRae
  90. Lindy McDaniel
  91. Willie McGee
  92. Don McMahon
  93. Kent Mercker
  94. Clarence Mitchell
  95. Yadier Molina
  96. Jack Morris
  97. Terry Mulholland
  98. Dale Murphy
  99. Mike Mussina
  100. Greg Myers
  101. Al Oliver
  102. David Ortiz
  103. Claude Osteen
  104. Tom Paciorek
  105. Raphael Palmeiro
  106. Dave Parker
  107. Camilo Pasquel
  108. Tony Peña
  109. Andy Pettitte
  110. Oliver Perez
  111. Dave Philley
  112. Tony Phillips
  113. Val Picinich
  114. Billy Pierce
  115. A.J. Pierzynski
  116. Lou Piniella
  117. Juan Pizarro
  118. Vada Pinson
  119. Dan Plesac
  120. Jamie Quirk
  121. Aramis Ramírez
  122. Manny Ramirez
  123. Willie Randolph
  124. Sam Rice
  125. Cal Ripken Jr.
  126. Ivan Rodriguez
  127. Kenny Rogers
  128. Edd Rousch
  129. Bill Russell
  130. C.C. Sabathia
  131. Ray Sadecki
  132. Ray Schalk
  133. Wally Schang
  134. Curt Schilling
  135. Mike Schmidt
  136. Luke Sewell
  137. Curt Simmons
  138. Lee Smith
  139. Ozzie Smith
  140. Duke Snider
  141. Sammy Sosa
  142. Warren Spahn
  143. Chris Speier
  144. Russ Springer
  145. Rick Sutcliffe
  146. Jim Thome
  147. Mike Timlin
  148. Joe Torre
  149. Mike Torrez
  150. Elmer Valo
  151. Mickey Vernon
  152. José Vizcaíno
  153. Omar Vizquel
  154. Adam Wainwright
  155. Dixie Walker
  156. Denny Walling
  157. Lloyd Waner
  158. David Weathers
  159. Frank White
  160. Billy Williams
  161. Ted Williams
  162. Jimmie Wilson
  163. Rick Wise
  164. Carl Yastrzemski
  165. Eddie Yost
Note: #25 Roy Campanella was mistakenly included in this list -- he has 18 professional seasons, but only 10 in MLB and thus only 10 in the WIS database, so I shouldn't have included him. His number came up in the randomized order, so I just skipped over it and didn't assign him to anyone.
3/26/2025 1:26 PM (edited)
Sorry for missing the sitemail, I'll be back!
3/25/2025 1:22 PM
Welcome back, Bob!

We need 4 more!
3/25/2025 7:12 PM
Sounds like a fun theme, sign me up!
3/25/2025 8:20 PM
Welcome, mcbillsfan!

We need 3 more!
3/25/2025 10:19 PM
Count me in please.
3/26/2025 1:55 AM
Welcome, gilh14!

We need 2 more!
3/26/2025 8:35 AM
Oh sure...add me.
3/26/2025 9:11 AM
Welcome, contrarian23!

We need 1 more!
3/26/2025 9:22 AM
I will take the final spot.
3/26/2025 12:29 PM
Welcome, dhomard!

We're full!

Randomized captains coming soon...
3/26/2025 1:14 PM (edited)
League # and deadline info has been sent out.

Waitlisters are still welcome.
3/26/2025 2:03 PM
RANDOM CAPTAIN 58—FULL Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.