SURVIVING THE SEASON
There are a lot of people that have had success in this game by simply turning the SIM manager on for all of the minor league levels and simply managing the Big Leagues. There are others that believe in religiously managing their minors in depth and could probably tell you the name and position of every player on every roster. I fall somewhere in between.
I do NOT believe in letting the SIM manage my minors. Simmy is dumb enough in some of the in-game moves it makes -- allowing him to run my entire farm system would be a very bad idea, in my opinion. I want to make certain that my prospects get playing time and that my pitchers arms don't get burned out, and I don't trust Simmy to do that for me. Plus, he likes to promote and demote guys - and I place players at a level for a reason and do not ant that guy moved up or down until I am ready to do it.
That said, I don't care about winning in the minors. I am not saying I root for those teams to lose. I like to see them win and be successful. But I don't go and adjust my lineup and pitching and the like in between each game. I just keep the teams healthy and let the games take care of themselves. (Note: All this changes when a minor league team makes the playoffs. once that happens, I do monitor each game and make moves to do my best to win the games).
Because I use 13 man pitching staffs with at least 4 long relievers, I find that pitching fatigue is rarely a problem. If my staff does get overly fatigues, I do have around 6 inactive pitchers that I can substitute in (I try to only sub in for non-prospects whenever possible).
So how do I handle my minors? Very simple. Once a day (for me usually in the morning), I go through my Manager's Office and look at my pitching staff and lineup for each minor league level. Any pitching staff that is showing fatigue problems, I make some quick active and inactive moves. By using the player note system to put a note on all prospects, when I go to switch guys on and off the active roster, I know exactly who I want to make certain stays active -- anyone with a note.
On the position player side, I will have 3 bench guys on my roster. If I see anyone below 100%, I bench them and sub in someone else. I don't move guys to active or inactive, and late in the season I sometimes find myself having to leave a guy who is 99 or 98% in the games because I have 4 or 5 guys with fatigue. However, I rarely let anyone go below that. Because a lot of people ignore their minors and let players play at low fatigues, I actually have an advantage in late season games which can equate to an extra win or two that might put my minor league team in to the playoffs.
If a player gets injured, I get an email. If the injury is less than 7 days, I just bench the guy. If it is 7 or more I move him to the 7 or 60 day DL and take one of the inactive players I have and put him in. When the guy is healthy, you get an email again and that is when I know to reactivate the injured guy. Of course, every move that involves switching out position players requires resetting Player Rest, Defensive Subs, and Pinch Hitting charts. Evey move that involves a new active pitcher requires a quick look at that guy's pitch count to make certain it is set properly (after a while you get a very good feel for what pitch counts are proper for the guy. If uncertain, I hit the "Show Recs" button, but do NOT save the Recs. I can then use the numbers given to give me an idea where to set a pitcher's numbers).
In addition to my once daily tour of the minors, I also check the Waiver Wire once per day and, if anyone is worth claiming, put in a claim. Make certain you check the guy's contract before you claim him. Last thing you want is to find out you just committed yourself to 10 million a year for the next 5 years!
I do not read minor league box scores unless a particular score looks interesting (or it is a playoff game). For example, I do briefly check every shutout to see if there was a no-hitter. By following this system, I can manage my minors without the need for Simmy and do it in about 5-10 minutes per team per day, if not less.
As for the big league team, I read those box scores in detail and may make lineup or pitching changes after each game. that is, in my opinion at least, what this game is really about after all.