My $140M team has 27 runs in 12 games... Usually, a player 350-400 OPS points worse than real life is leading the league as biggest underachiever...
How's this for the underachieving Hall of Fame
'46 Musial 1.021 OPS in real life vs .704 (a difference of .317)
'18 Ruth .965 vs .610 (.345)
'89 Bonilla .848 vs .471 (.377)
'20 Hornsby .990 vs .572 (.418)
'43 Musial .988 vs .566 (.422)
'44 Musial .990.vs .451 (.449)
'95 Bonilla .936 vs .348 (.588)
My ten players' sim batting averages are --> .091, .116, .163, .171, .200, .229, .244, .250, .255, 297
Same ten players real life batting averages -> .333, .281, .347, .299, .300, .357, .322, .370, ..365, .332
Seems reasonable.