'74 Gene Tenace. There's really no reason not to use him or '75 Gary Carter unless you're doing something special - they throw of 50% of baserunners and can bat 8th/9th fairly comfortably.

e by "something special" i mean looking specifically for a good offensive catcher = 1996 Todd Hundley, 1891 Jocko Milligan, maybe some others. Oh, 1968 Johnny Bench hits a truckload of doubles and has a great arm, pity about the .330 OBP.

i'm looking at both good defensivly Charles Johnson(atleast he has some pop) or Matt Walbeck (terrible average)

Batting average is for sissies. Dave Kingman is the greatest player who ever lived.

It was between 1893Jack Clements or a Randy Hundley(super D). This time I went with the O (Jack Clements) instead of the D just to experiment and see what happens.