I know this isn't what Jt is looking for, but I've got Ryan in a progressive league and through 5 seasons (1980-1984), he is 85-51, with a 3.61 ERA. Not great, but not too bad either.
But as far as an OL or theme league, there are just too many better options for the $/IP. That's why I like progressives so much...players you don't normally use get a chance to shine (or suck).