That's 6 guys, so I'm not sure what you're doing.
The way I was building teams toward the end of the last roster (because I haven't put a team together AND run it in a league since), I tried to get one guy with 32.5%+ usage and one guy between 22.1% to 27.5%. I had a third guy in the 17.5% to 22.1% tier, and the rest lower (or at most like that third guy). I found this to be the most efficient way to make sure I got every ounce of good out of every player without hitting the usage penalty too much. I tried with the highest guy being in the 27.5% tier, but I had a lot of personal turnover spikes from everyone (though I still won the whole thing, so I'd say I was okay with it) because they all handled the ball a little more than they should have.