Since the topic of who or who should not be in Cooperstown, how about we decide who deserves to be in the SIM HOF?

I nominate 1985 Willie McGee for Centerfield.

Amy turned me on to him when we were partners and I use him all the time. He is always money no matter what field he plays on. He wins the MVP alot and is a benefit in centerfield.

Yes she hooked me up with him also.Great player!!!!

Is it the Hall of Fame or Hall of Value?

My HoV post-update:

C: '92 Daly, '91 Farrell
1B: '93 Jefferies, '01 Freeman
2B: ?
SS: ?
COF: '98 Henderson, '22 Williams
CF: ?

I can go the other direction and say that Joe Morgan is a HOF in 'real life', but a total Hall of Shamer in WIS.

I think HOF total value all time (not just since the update)

I nominate starting pitcher Bob Caruthers '86. The total package, pitched lots of innings and hit like a fiend.

I thought he was a hated guy around here?

It's a niche, but greatest Game 1 playoff starter:

Bob Milaki

Quote: Originally posted by micki on 2/16/2010I thought he was a hated guy around here? 

Well I do know that Amycox hated his gut's.

85 Mcgee is on just about every team i have! Pete Rose is money as well ecspecially in proggys! Addie Joss(08) is dominating...And Mo Rivera is a force in real life and the sim!

If HOF is a "value" proposition, then you have to have the 1993 Tony Phillips as your second baseman

23 cy williams, 94-95 maddux

My all-time sim-HOFers:
C: '77 Gene Tenace
1B: '93 John Olerud
2B: '93 Tony Phillips
3B: '88 Wade Boggs
SS: '95 Walt Weiss
OF: '54 Richie Ashburn
OF: '28 Taylor Douthit
OF: '88 Kirby Puckett
SP: '94 Greg Maddux, '95 Greg Maddux, '00 Pedro Martinez, '96 Kevin Brown, '06 Doc White
RP: '88 Bob Milacki, '88 Elton Chamberlain, '11 Fred Toney, '43 Johnny Niggeling, '18 Jake Northrop, '67 Cisco Carlos

I nominate the following for the $80 MM OL HOF --

Willie McGee `85 (consistently insane stats in dozens of leagues)

Addie Joss `08 (the best big money pitcher dollar-for-dollar)

Addie Joss `04 (the best value Joss)

Greg Maddux `95

Tim Raines `87

Cy Williams `23

Willie Wilson `79 (consistently over 100 SB/season)

Greg Jefferies `93

Doc White `06

Ferdie Schupp `16

John Smoltz `03

Dizzy Dean `38

Dutch Leonard `14

Ted Simmons `71

Jake Northrop `18 (yeah, yeah, I know)

Cisco Carlos `67

Quote: Originally Posted By zubinsum on 2/16/2010
Is it the Hall of Fame or Hall of Value?

My HoV post-update:

C: '92 Daly, '91 Farrell
1B: '93 Jefferies, '01 Freeman
2B: ?
SS: ?
COF: '98 Henderson, '22 Williams
CF: ?

You can't be in the HOF if a majority of voters have never heard of you, sorry. He has only been used 3 times and his numbers were...average at best. Same with '98 Rickey.

Does Max Bishop deserve a place in our HOF? He used to be the best.

Cy Williams definitely needs to be on the list. I would also add Spud Chandler '43 to my personal HoF.