Hehe ok I'll tell you the secret.
First pick a 25IP-30IP pitcher for your specialist. Any more and they won't get enough innings just like the 80IP 1 inning closer. Plus I never spend over $1M for a specialist, its overkill. You don't need an ace to be your specialist, just someone who's ok.
Next make sure you have enough in the bullpen, in both innings and number of pitchers. If there's noone available they put your specialist in no matter what.
Once the specialist comes in, the other ratings takes over. I put my guy for 5-10-4, even if it means they'll keep him in for one or two more batters occasionally, righty or lefty. This is what fills out the innings for me.
In my current league my LHS is '88 Randy Johnson ($478K, remember you don't need an ace ). In 49 games so far, he played in 17 games, and 9.1 IP (which is right on pace). I also have 350IP+ and 5 other pitchers in the bullpen, not including my AAA mopups, so I don't have to worry about stretching out the bullpen. In those 17 games, only one time has he come in for a righty, and a couple of times for a switch hitter. The rest has been all lefties. Once again they'll leave him in for the next batter many times even if its a righty, but I'm fine with that to fill in the innings.
7/3/2010 9:19 AM (edited)