1923 Cy Williams - $6,204,406
1979 Willie Wilson - $5,697,394
1995 Walt Weiss - $3,759,477
1985 Willie McGee - $7,137,439
1993 Greg Jefferies - $6,255,139
2000 Luis Castillo - $5,231,487
1936 Luke Appling - $8,221,956
1918 George Sisler - $6,814,491
1971 Ted Simmons - $4,847,408
1980 Miguel Dilone - $4,387,671
Other catchers I can think of, off-hand:
1975 Gary Carter - $3,936,483
1974 Gene Tenace - $3,784,446
Honus Wagner looks to have most of his years around C/A. Gavvy's go from D/D- to C/B-.
Edit: And I just checked the pitchers sheet again. They have not fixed the salaries yet so it is impossible to look them up. I would expect guys like 1886 Bob to take a huge hike.