Good point. I was just looking at plus plays among all fielders. I checked four long-running progs/themes I'm in (about 200 seasons total) and Bancroft was the only player with over 50 plus plays at any position. Based on those leagues and d_rock's post above, here's what I came up with for most plus plays at every position:
P -- 2004 Livan Hernandez, 14
C -- a bunch of guys with 1
1B -- 1914 George Burns, 39
2B -- 1906 Nap Lajoie, 55
3B -- 1912 Frank Baker, 37
SS -- 1920 Dave Bancroft, 52
LF -- 1930 Mule Haas, 47
CF -- 1923 Johnny Mostil, 46
RF -- 1928 Taylor Douthit , 35
If anyone can find examples that top the totals listed here, please share them.
EDIT: Above list updated based on new posts below.
1/30/2020 12:13 PM (edited)