Big post coming here...
Last season: Richmond went the hardest-luck 17-11 I've ever seen. Of 11 losses, nine were by five points or fewer. I'm not saying we were great, but we should've won 20 games and didn't, so that hurts. In addition, our prestige dropped to C+, which I figured would hurt us in recruiting.
This season: Things went much, much better. We've completed a 20-6 regular season with some big wins, including a road win at Georgia. WIS says we're on the right side of the NT bubble, and that's nice to see.
We had three scholarships to fill in recruiting, and all three got filled up early. Here's what we got...
Daniel Murphy (**, #122 overall, #29 SG) - This was another terrible guard year (though, to be fair, it comes after a string of decent ones). Murphy was one of two primary targets. Another, a *** guard, was the subject of a battle between Richmond and Georgia. Georgia won the flip, but I don't regret going after him because I HAD to dig my heels in somewhere.
Murphy, meanwhile, has a listed position that doesn't match his skill set. It says he's a guard, but he's really a SF. Currently, he's slow for a guard, and he can't really shoot. What he CAN do, however, is guard like crazy and move the ball. He hits me like a "point forward" type, one who'll get much faster and turn into a solid dribble-drive guy on offense. Down the road, it's possible he moves back to a guard spot, depending on how the roster shapes up.
We do, however, have to start him next year. Maryland Eastern Shore dumped a lot of attention on him. I was OK battling them (a lower-prestige program from a lower-level league), but then I saw Binghamton offered him a scholarship and I pulled out the promises to keep this from turning into a three-way battle. Thankfully, he knows both of my sets and shouldn't be a liability, and long-term, he'll be a very good player with a defined role. There'll be growing pains, but for what he is, I really like him.
David Wiggins (*, #147 overall, #35 PF) - The frontcourt isn't a pressing need for next season. We return the four PF's/C's that have played every game. However, two of those guys will be seniors next season, and I remain convinced Amezcua's going to turn pro early.
Enter Wiggins, who has plenty of potential but needs time. He's a good athlete already, with good "wing" stats for a big and a knowledge of my defense. Most everywhere else, though, he's pretty raw (I also wish he had a higher rebounding ceiling, but it's not like he'll be terrible on the glass, either). He's going to develop a lot in time, and that makes him a prime redshirt candidate. If he doesn't take it, it's not the end of the world, but more time to ensure he reaches his ceiling will turn him into a solid starter.
Anthony Gerhardt (#63 SF; ineligible) - It's been a while since I went down the "sign an ineligible" route, but having plugged the other gaps, there wasn't much available other than what was being fought over by lesser-prestige schools. Sim teams Canisius and Niagara were battling for Gerhardt, but I was able to swoop in and sign him without much of a fight.
Gerhardt's a decent long-term prospect. Down the road, he'll be an excellent defender, with good ATH/speed he can use on both ends. I wish he was a better passer, but he'll turn into an OK complementary scorer who also won't commit many turnovers. In a vacuum, he makes a lot of sense for us, but I'm not entirely sure how much he'll play. Everything he does, Murphy is going to do better, and if he shows up and sits a year, he won't develop until that second season (where it's possible he'll be third-string at SF and not really able to contribute anywhere else). Ability-wise, though, I don't have many concerns.
GRADE: B. Getting the *** guard would've helped us a ton, but I landed my other primary target and snatched up two other guys who'll fit long-term. Given the recent prestige drop, I did pretty well, and I'm hoping that bounces back up at the end of this season.