Savage XI Rosters/Commentary Topic

some player season omissions i noticed when checking rosters....

jethroeg - 93-94 and 94-95 shaq

jethro noooo! what are you doing here? two of his highest min seasons! cant be the defense since you went with 97-98 shaq...im baffled

jpevans31 - 71-72 and 72-73 cliff ray

those are 2 of the 3 reasons why you would draft cliff ray! elite rebounding! the towels scare you off i guess? maybe the lower efg?

24kpyrite - 11-12 dwight

this one i kinda get...you paired 16-17 dwight with the best(89-90) ewing...im guessing you didnt need the extra usage and the higher efg/oreb was more important...id have a hard time passing up the higher mins/usg/def of 11-12 tho...3.7 fp48 in 11-12 too

pbandj - 89-90 and 90-91 rodman

3 seasons of rodman at pf....whhhyyyyyyy!!!! you have ben wallace and towns!...so i guess those 3 will form a roatation at the 4/5? thats a usage nightmare...i really think you needed a high usg backup for towns...maybe im a bit biased because i failed miserably playing him at pf, but rodman should always be at sf in savage

albiband0 - 68-69 wilt

71-72 has better defense(100 to 80) but thats about it...i dont think low usage 70s wilt should ever be used in savage...give me the extra paint scoring

chewy3344 - 97-98 duncan

im thinking it was the tov% and lower dreb%? tough to leave out 1000 more mins and +5 efg tho

raggedclaws - 06-07 dirk

no mvp dirk? gotta be the lower per% right? seems to be the only thing 16-17 has got on 06-07

benhoidal - 93-94 drob

lower efg% and dreb% then 94-95 but i always had a had a soft spot for mvp drob...i love the 14.7 ast% and he absolutely lives at the ft line

edsortails - 96-97 stockton

its the 2nd best stockton! and you needed the 3s

ashamael - 06-07 chandler

im guessing defense? its the best rebounding chandler with the 3rd most mins so i was a bit surprised

midge - 18-19 or 19-20 jokic

not too surprising but i thought you might go for the higher usg or more mins






5/11/2023 7:32 PM
I've got 06-07 Dirk - check W1.

Dirk was a little tricky but I felt good about my selections - my toughest omission was probably 00-01 but I replaced it with 13-14, which I'm playing at SF for about 24 of his 32 minutes.

I have 94-95 DRob slightly higher than 93-94 as well, but agree it's close. 94-95 has the EFG, boards, and only 37 fewer makes from the line on 78 fewer attempts. $/min concurs, too, despite fewer mins and lower usage.

Agree with you on 11-12 Dwight, I've got that as 4th best with a fairly big gap between that and #5. But yeah in context I can see going with a lower usage season.
5/11/2023 8:12 PM (edited)
You got it with the towels, dh. My TOs were so high teamwide that I got scurred. Hoping my good rebs at PG/SG make up for that, but it might've been a bad call.
5/11/2023 8:05 PM
Posted by dh555 on 5/11/2023 6:17:00 PM (view original):

There were 24 items in your list. Here they are in random order:

  1. jethroeg
  2. robusk
  3. dh555
  4. raggedclaws
  5. ashamael
  6. dbkc
  7. steelers821
  8. benhoidal
  9. jpevans31
  10. ty84moss
  11. albiband0
  12. pbandj
  13. 20ks
  14. edsortails
  15. 24kpyrite
  16. chewy3344
  17. jhsukow
  18. midge
  19. jkaye24
  20. gerryred
  21. berkelon
  22. amerk1180
  23. ncmusician_7
  24. jcred5

IP: 2601:41:c300:58e0:7430:abaa:7027:2a40
Timestamp: 2023-05-11 22:17:05 UTC

Division World 1 World 2 World 3 World 4 World 5
Div 1 edsortails midge benhoidal raggedclaws albiband0
Div 1 dh555 jhsukow 20ks gerryred 24kpyrite
Div 1 steelers821 jpevans31 midge ashamael jpevans31
Div 1 20ks raggedclaws ty84moss benhoidal 20ks
Div 1 pbandj ty84moss jethroeg jethroeg benhoidal
Div 1 24kpyrite gerryred pbandj dbkc gerryred
Div 2 jpevans31 albiband0 raggedclaws steelers821 dbkc
Div 2 dbkc edsortails berkelon robusk jhsukow
Div 2 benhoidal jcred5 jpevans31 berkelon pbandj
Div 2 ty84moss berkelon dbkc ty84moss ashamael
Div 2 chewy3344 dh555 24kpyrite jhsukow robusk
Div 2 jcred5 jethroeg amerk1180 pbandj dh555
Div 3 gerryred steelers821 jhsukow albiband0 jcred5
Div 3 jhsukow chewy3344 ashamael jpevans31 steelers821
Div 3 jkaye24 robusk ncmusician_7 chewy3344 berkelon
Div 3 ncmusician_7 20ks dh555 dh555 midge
Div 3 amerk1180 jkaye24 jcred5 amerk1180 amerk1180
Div 3 jethroeg dbkc steelers821 20ks jkaye24
Div 4 albiband0 ncmusician_7 gerryred 24kpyrite ncmusician_7
Div 4 berkelon 24kpyrite jkaye24 jkaye24 ty84moss
Div 4 midge ashamael chewy3344 ncmusician_7 jethroeg
Div 4 raggedclaws benhoidal albiband0 jcred5 edsortails
Div 4 ashamael amerk1180 edsortails midge chewy3344
Div 4 robusk pbandj robusk edsortails raggedclaws
5/11/2023 8:36 PM
Row Labels Sum of AvgWins
W4, Div 4 261
W2, Div 3 261
W3, Div 3 255
W1, Div 4 254
W3, Div 4 254
W1, Div 2 253
W5, Div 2 253
W2, Div 4 250
W4, Div 1 248
W5, Div 3 247
W5, Div 4 246
W3, Div 2 246
W2, Div 1 244
W1, Div 1 240
W4, Div 3 238
W5, Div 1 237
W4, Div 2 236
W1, Div 3 234
W2, Div 2 227
W3, Div 1 226
5/11/2023 8:46 PM
Glancing at the combined numbers, the toughest division draws:
  • steelers821
  • jcred5
  • dBKC
  • jkaye24
  • robusk
the weakest division draws:
  • 20ks
  • benhoidal
  • ty82moss
  • dh555
  • pbandj
5/11/2023 8:47 PM
My weakest teams gets to share a division with ash and raggedclaws while my second weakest team gets to share a division with ash, dBKC and dh555. Woohoo!!!
5/11/2023 8:51 PM
Posted by robusk on 5/11/2023 8:51:00 PM (view original):
My weakest teams gets to share a division with ash and raggedclaws while my second weakest team gets to share a division with ash, dBKC and dh555. Woohoo!!!
Do you have any math on who gets screwed the most on these things? I feel like I’m in the “toughest draws” column every season.
5/11/2023 9:17 PM
Posted by dBKC on 5/11/2023 9:17:00 PM (view original):
Posted by robusk on 5/11/2023 8:51:00 PM (view original):
My weakest teams gets to share a division with ash and raggedclaws while my second weakest team gets to share a division with ash, dBKC and dh555. Woohoo!!!
Do you have any math on who gets screwed the most on these things? I feel like I’m in the “toughest draws” column every season.
Last season I was supposed to have a cake draw and ended up with a pretty hard one. Let’s see what happens.
5/11/2023 9:21 PM
This seems unfortunate.
5/11/2023 9:31 PM
Posted by steelers821 on 5/11/2023 9:31:00 PM (view original):
This seems unfortunate.
Well, walk through it with me... a few coaches who repeat in your divisions all have super high averages but at least have some people thinking they could have down seasons. History says they will crush it but if they do have down seasons then the people like you or dBKC who have "tough" divisions because they are lined up against them will be in good shape.

Last season I was supposed to have a cakewalk but it was dependent on jethro, pbandj and gerryred being as bad as expected and they were all much better so I went from among the easiest expected draws to a top five hardest draw.

The preseason averages for the divisions are usually a better predictor than Joe Shmo pointing his finger in the air... they are more right than wrong, but plenty of times they are wrong.
5/11/2023 9:43 PM
@dh: rooting for your team and having to watch ******* Tatum of all people get his **** together at the end is just disgusting. That ending was brutal. The 6ers have deprived me of Simmons tears, the sustenance on which I feed.
5/11/2023 10:10 PM

ashamael - 06-07 chandler

im guessing defense? its the best rebounding chandler with the 3rd most mins so i was a bit surprised


I have him as the sixth best per minute version. Total minutes gives him a slight edge over 1-4, but season 5 has even more minutes than that one so... it's tough.
5/11/2023 10:16 PM
Okay, here's the breakdown:

Starters:
Category Uno Dos Tres Quatro Cinco
Min 12,360 11,941 12,748 13,505 13,386
usg% 105.3 106.3 105.5 104.1 101.4
efg% 57.0 59.1 56.1 55.2 56.7
ts% 63.0 63.7 60.2 61.3 59.8
ast% 74.3 85.8 79.1 75.7 76.1
tov% 12.8 14.8 14.3 13.8 13.9
orb% 34.8 36.6 36.2 35.6 36.1
drb% 98.5 96.4 98.0 92.9 92.7
crb% 133.3 133.0 134.2 128.5 128.8
def 81.2 77.2 74.2 67.6 65.6
stl% 9.5 8.0 7.8 6.9 7.2
blk% 9.3 10.2 9.2 8.3 7.5
fouled% 11.4 12.1 10.3 13.1 10.0
Category Uno Dos Tres Quatro Cinco
Min 19,680 19,680 19,680 19,680 19,680
usg% 109.7 102.7 103.5 103.1 100.6
efg% 55.9 56.3 55.5 55.0 55.4
ts% 59.5 60.4 59.3 59.5 58.4
ast% 73.7 74.9 70.9 74.1 68.0
tov% 12.9 13.8 14.0 13.9 13.3
orb% 35.3 35.8 34.3 36.0 34.3
drb% 96.8 95.0 95.3 91.6 93.7
crb% 132.1 130.7 129.5 127.6 128.0
def 71.1 71.4 70.9 65.7 64.9
stl% 8.8 7.5 7.8 7.2 7.5
blk% 9.4 8.8 9.2 9.0 8.0
fouled% 10.2 11.1 10.3 11.7 9.6
pf48 17.77 17.31 19.22 18.29 17.68
3pm 493 582 521 494 499


Team name does not correspond with world fyi.

Thoughts: This turned out better than I thought but worse than I hoped. I feel like I have two good teams, two whatever teams, and one absolute **** show. Shooting, dimes, and threes are nice, but defense, boards, and turnovers are less than desirable. Lack of steals and a low fouled% means fewer easy possessions and less punishment for teams who went high on TOs and PFs. I haven't looked at division layout yet.
5/11/2023 10:20 PM (edited)
There are no "easy" draws in Savage. There's only less difficult.

That said, I have ben 2x, rob 2x, and nc 2x, three guys I consider top 5 all-time in WISNBA, plus a host of other loaded owners. World 2, Division 4 looks like hell.
5/11/2023 10:28 PM
◂ Prev 1...24|25|26|27|28...42 Next ▸
Savage XI Rosters/Commentary Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2024 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.