I have so many issues with defense in the sim but I get this isn't the forum for it, so I'll table that for another day.
I'll just say with regards to players like Tatum, Luka, Booker, basically anyone who played substantial minutes on one of the most dominant defenses in the league, which all of them did, my feeling is they better see a defensive bump. It may not be a bump of 20 or 30, it might just be a 5 pt jump, but there should be some more respect given, considering they're a big part of that defensive identity. If Booker were truly a 30 defensive player in real life, that would mean he's one of the biggest defensive liabilities in the game. Putting a historically dreadful defensive player out there for 35-40 minutes and in the final minutes of close games, would make becoming a top 5 team defense insanely difficult, I don't care how good your help defense is. Ratings this low are unbelievably disrespectful. That's not just failing, that's getting 30 on a 100 point scale. You'd be held back in school every year if you scored 30's. That's a 480 on your SATs. Give em bumps simmy!