I'd give it a try if there is space left...

sounds like a challenge. signs me up.

1. 1908 Jack Flater and teammate Harry Coveleski
2. 1920 Chicago Cubs - Tom Daly and Charlie Hollocher
3. 2002 Pirates- Jason Kendall and Adam Hyzdu
4. OF Tod Dennehey 1923 Phillies- (AAA 1963 Matty Alou will sent down) and replaced with AAA 1923 LH OF Casey Stengel/ also Phillies teammate Cotton Tierney
5. 1953 Pirates- Danny O'Connell and Dick Cole
6. Scipio Spinks and teammate 1971 Astro Larry Dierker
7. 1887 Louisville Colonels- Lave Cross and Pete Browning (Had to have one .400 hitter)
8. OF Jack Ryan 1929 Red Sox- (AAA 1973 Jesus Alou will be sent down) and replaced by RH OF Chico Salmon/ also Red Sox teammate Ken Williams 
9. P Ed McCreery 1914 Tigers- (AAA 1914 Guy Cooper will be sent down( and replaced by RH pitcher 1915 Cy Falkenberg and Tigers teammate Sam Crawford
10. Box score 9/15/2009 A's and Rangers- Cliff Pennington A's and Neftali Feliz Rangers
11.1924 Cardinals- Jim Bottomley and Bill Doak
12. Jean Dubuc 1908-19 (1912) and 1919 Art Nehf

Wild Card 1918 Carl Mays and Stadium is Busch Stadium

burningcouch:  Thanks for volunteering!  You're in ... and here are your 12 random pages:

1.  box score 8/27/2009  Padres at Braves  [any two players who appeared in that game, no twisting]
2.  INF  Kevin Jordan  1995-2001
3.  * 1B  Jimmy Hudgens  1923-26  [pick-your-own AAA left-handed 1B for Hudgens, plus a teammate from 1923, 25 or 26]
4.  P  Ken Ash  1925-30

5.  * P  Terry Enyart  1974  [pick-your-own LHP, plus an Expos teammate]
6.  P  Gene Snyder  1959
7.  P  Gene Walter  1985-88
8.  1970 National League Advanced Batting  [any two players from the NL in 1970, incl. pitchers]

9.  * OF  Red Connally  1886  [pick-your-own switch-hitting OF, plus a teammate on the 1886 Maroons]
10.  P  Gary Lavelle  1974-87
11.  254 players died in New Jersey  [any two, in any season of their careers ... includes 5 Hall of Famers]
12.  2006 Chicago Cubs fielding statistics  [any two players on that team, no twisting]

Should be a very interesting build ... good luck!

sjh0825:  You're our 24th man!  Thank you and here is your draw:

1.  2B  John Atz  1902-09
2.  P  Luke Gregerson  2009-14
3.  OF  Sam Jethroe  1950-54
4.  OF  Jerry Hairston  1973-89

5.  OF  Bunny Roser  1922
6.  * C  Julio Mosquera  1996-2005  [pick-your-own AAA right-handed C for Mosquera, plus a teammate with Toronto or Milwaukee]
7.  P  Angel Miranda  1993-97
8.  OF-1B-3B  Dan Meyer  1974-85

9.  2003 Toronto Blue Jays batting statistics  [page does list all pitchers for the team, even though many of them did not have a plate appearance, you can use all]
10.  3B  Jose Oliva  1994-95
11.  box score  5/7/2009  Tigers at White Sox
12.  * SS-2B  George Wright  1871-82  [one of the pioneers of the game, a bare-handed SS who barnstormed for Washington and Cincinnati even before the founding of the National Association!  Pick-your-own AAA right-handed SS or 2B for Wright, plus any teammate he had with a sim-eligible season]

I hope you can find a AAA shortstop worthy of replacing the great George Wright.  Good luck with your club!

Hopefully that puts us at 24 again, including my second team as drafted by dcmatcheck.  If someone else wants to join, I will happily draft 12 more pages and give up my second team ... but let's hope we can get the league going by the end of this week!

Actually it looks like I'm the 25th man.  Too bad, because one of my random draws [1961 National League hitters] would have allowed me to take a vintage Ernie Banks!  But I hope we have burning couch and sjh0825's teams instead.  Thanks to everyone for their patience.

Here's my back-up team, just for fun:

1. 1915 Pittsburgh Pirates roster
   1915 Al Mamaux
   1915 George Gibson

2. Paul Foytack 1953-1964
     1958 Paul Foytack
     1958 Herm Wehmeier

3. Joe Ross, coach at the University of Washington, 1993-2008. (Pick any sim eligible Huskie who played for him, found here: http://www.baseball-reference.com/schools/washington.shtml. The most prominent one is Tim Lincecum)
     1993 Kevin Stocker
     2008 Tim Lincecum

4. 1966 Philadelphia Phillies roster
     1966 Dick Allen
     1966 Tony Gonzalez

5. Mike James 1995-2002
     2000 Mike James
     2000 Mark McGwire

6. 1999 MLB standard pitching (any 2 pitchers from 1999)
     1999 Mariano Rivera
     1999 Matt Whisenant

7. 2004 Arizona Diamondbacks roster
     2004 Randy Johnson
     2004 Matt Kata

8. 1961 NL player value (any 2 NL players from 1961)
     1961 Ernie Banks
     1961 Roberto Clemente

9. Catcher Tony Hellman, 1886 Baltimore Orioles (will need to rename AAA replacement)
     1886 Abner Powell  [to be replaced]
     1886 Billy Taylor

10. OF Chick Hartley, 1902 NY Giants (will need to rename AAA replacement)
     1904 Claude Rossman  [to be replaced]
     1902 Joe McGinnity

11. 1b Kerby Farrell, 1943-1945
     1943 Kerby Farrell
     1943 Heinie Hetzel

12. 1910 Boston Doves roster
     1910  Fred Beck
     1910 Kirby White

Wild Card:  1980 Willie Randolph

Stadium:  Connie Mack Stadium, home of the 1966 Phillies

This could get ugly quickly but here is the roster (managed to score a couple home state men from WV :) )

1. 2009's Brian McCann and Martin Prado
2. 1997 Kevin Jordan and Curt Schilling
3. 200k swap and 1923 Rogers Hornsby
4. 1930 Ken Ash and Goose Goslin
5. 200k swap and 1974 Dale Murray
6. 1959 Gene Snyder and Don Drysdale
7. 1988 Gene Walter and Mike Moore
8. 1970 Ken Holtzman and Jim McAndrew
9. 200k swap and 1886 Jack Glasscock
10. 1983 Gary Lavelle and Duane Kuiper
11. Dan Brouthers and Harry Heilman
12. 2006 Henry Blanco and Aramis Ramirez
Wildcard is 2014 Aaron Sanchez

Let me know if it is good - have already swapped names for my replacements.

OH...and stadium Sportsmans Park III (home of the 1930 Goose Goslin)

burningcouch:  Your team looks good to go.  See you in the league:  MLB111366.

1. 1908 Atz and 1908 Ed Walsh
2. 2010 Gregerson and Oscar Salazar
3. 50 Jethro and 50 Sid Gordon
4. 85 Hairston and 85 Bob James
5. 22 Roser and 22 Johnny Clooney
6. aaa and 2005 Geoff Jenkins
7.1993 Miranda and 1993 Jesse Orosco
8. 1983 Meyer and 83 Mike Warren
9. 2003 Aquilino Lopez and 2003 Carlos Delgado
10. 94 Oliva and 94 Greg Maddux
11. 2009 Josh Fields and 2009 Clete Thomas
12. aaa and 1887 John Ward (Monte)

wild card: 2005 Chipper Jones

toughest draft I remember Let me know if there are any errors. thanks

sjh:  The draft is even tougher than that ... there is no twisting of teammates ... so if you're going to take 2010 Gregerson you need a 2010 teammate, etc.  Looks like you have 4 or 5 to change.  We do have a couple of others with roster issues, so you can take a day to fix it; two if necessary.

I guess the lists of players from the pages were just the length they played, not the years you could draft from. Many were years they played but not sim eligible so now I see you couldn't use those years of team mates.

It should be correct now. Let me know if I need any changes. Thanks

1. 1908 Atz and 1908 Ed Walsh
2. 2010 Gregerson and Oscar Salazar
3. 50 Jethro and 50 Sid Gordon
4. 85 Hairston and 85 Bob James
5. 22 Roser and 22 Johnny Clooney
6. aaa and 2005 Geoff Jenkins
7.1993 Miranda and 1993 Jesse Orosco
8. 1983 Meyer and 83 Mike Warren
9. 2003 Aquilino Lopez and 2003 Carlos Delgado
10. 94 Oliva and 94 Greg Maddux
11. 2009 Josh Fields and 2009 Clete Thomas
12. aaa and 1887 John Ward (Monte)

wild card: 2005 Chipper Jones