Posted by nachopuzzle on 5/8/2014 7:02:00 PM (view original):
I'm not saying I don't think it's collusion (and I don't use these tactics), but how is that information not available to everybody...if you don't know something simply because you failed to ask, then??????
The case, in my opinion, that could truly be viewed as collusion is if a coach only gave that info to some users and not others.
hey nacho, if you were to say, as long as the coach tells everyone who asks, if he tells at least one person - then it would be ok for me to ask the top local coaches who they were going for, and if they answered, and nobody asked, now i would have a tremendous advantage - i could then avoid all those players! that is basically collusion at its worst. i guess it doesn't really make sense to me that the mechanism of asking somehow makes a difference - collusion in HD is getting information from a coach that gives you an advantage over other coaches.
also, FYI, seble has already made WIS's stance on this clear - asking for information like this is collusion - regardless of if you get an answer or not!! he even said, specifically, its collusion to ask the coach of a transfer, what that transfer's potential was. that is terribly minor compared to information about who someone is recruiting, but thats not allowed, so the case in this thread definitely is not allowed!