Here is another guy who calls bullshit:
Hardball Dynasty – Fantasy Baseball Sim Games - Player Profile: Dennys Mullins
On opening day last season, my #1 starter and the previous season's Cy Young winner went down with a half season long injury. After scanning my entire system and the available free agents, I thought my best option was to call him up to the Bigs instead of pitching him at High A or AA. (Can't remember where I was going to use him and yes, I know he never should have been in Rookie ball.) He progressed just fine, came within a few votes of ROY, and is still improving this season as well. Thanks to his help we earned a wild card birth.