The very 1st ODL I was in you said the only thing consistent in the sim is rebounding, and that has certainly been the case with me lately. My results have gotten progressively wierder so I am not happy about it.
I realize none of the sims is perfect: In the baseball sim you can do 100 leagues and every single pitcher in every one of those leagues will have a higher whip than his real life stats. Needless to say, the hitters will all do better too, especially .230 hitting no power utility guys. But you know that going in, (or figure it out quickly) so you nver spend money on a 1.08 whip Ace when a 1.38 whip journeyman will end up with identical stats. (About a 1.50 whip).
In HBD, you know that 2 pitchers, one a starter and one a reliever, with absolutely identical ratings, will end up with the reliever ALWAYS having a much worse whip. The HBD engine is extremely hinky for generating 10 run innings, always by the bullpen. So you dont waste picks or spend money on bullpen.
The basketball sim also has it peculiarities- the one definitive thing it that can be said is that it favors offense, beyond that its only consistency is inconsistency.
In any case, other money I have already spent, I am close to the end at WIS, as I would rather do Chess or Bridge.