The first number is their current level of fatigue, and the second number is what their fatigue will be after one more game of rest. If they are under 90%, the number turns blue, and if it's below 70% (I'm not totally sure on that number) it is red. The colors only serve as a quick visual to see which of your pitchers are fatigued. There is a lot of strategy in figuring out the best way to manage fatigue, but if you're seeing a lot of red and blue, you are playing fatigued pitchers who are not going to perform as well as if they were fully rested.