Similar problem here with passing and can't get the running game off the ground either. Out of every 10 games, I might get one 200 yard game out of my QB, yet he'll rush 8 times for 90 yards (setting is for him to rush 0), so he's obviously scrambling. I've tried all pass, very short, short, medium, long, deep in every formation. My QB isn't completely terrible at a 43 rating and O line in the 50's, but I've tried both all run and all pass and balance with different pass aggression and blocking schemes and I'm pretty much getting owned in the test games. I've been hearing people say the running stats were way too high... Not sure what you guys are doing, but I'd certainly like to know what to try. I've tried inside running, outside running, switching up my backs (granted, they're not all that great, but this is D-III so they're not necessarily playing against great d's either). Been trying not to jump around too much and just test one group of things, but when I can't get anything working, I end up going back to the drawing board, which doesn't seem to help either.
Sacks are what seem way up to me. My qb isn't getting sacked all that much, but my defense (set from 5 to 15% blitz with probably an average of 10% or less) is getting almost 10 sacks a game. That seems high for 10%